Spending Halloween with his football teammates at the haunted estate where he had an encounter with the paranormal, Jasper Rome hopes he'll find answers to the questions he's carried for a decade. As the scares mount, the kicker turns to his best friend Poe, but leaning on him risks revealing feelings Jasper is desperate to keep hidden.

Poe Macleod believes in the paranormal, but is suspicious and skeptical of a haunted house that guarantees ghostly encounters. What starts as an evening of offering support for his best friend also gives the long snapper a taste of what things would be like if he breaks his rule about not getting involved with a teammate.

But the estate isn't the only place where the unknown lurks. Taking a step into deepening their relationship beyond friendship might be the scariest thing of all.