Lacey realizes, after breaking off two and a half engagements, she will never find the romantic love she has always dreamed about, and decides to help others find theirs instead. The Café on the Corner, where she has breakfast every morning, is fertile people-watching territory, and after she successfully brings one couple together, she knows the possibilities for making matches for others are endless.

When Lacey has a chance encounter with Hunter at the café, she enlists his aid in matchmaking. Hunter learns of Lacey's broken engagements and the fact she is convinced she will never have her own happily ever after, and he decides he will be the one to prove her wrong.