With the bishop's daughter suddenly missing and a new sheriff in town, Anna and Beth find themselves roped into solving another mystery in their small town.

Levi expects to meet Ruby at their secret spot in the woods, but she is nowhere to be found. Due to a disagreement earlier that day at the breakfast table, Ruby's father is faced with a battle of pride as the bishop of the Amish community. But when Ruby doesn't come home for dinner, he and his wife begin to worry that Ruby's disappearance might be more than just a teenage temper tantrum.

The new sheriff of Little Valley works hard to uncover all the secrets surrounding Ruby's disappearance and rebuild the community's confidence in the law. But he realizes he can't do it alone. He reaches out to the trusted wise women and amateur investigators, Anna and Beth, for help.

Everywhere the twin sisters turn, another secret is revealed, but the biggest secret of all is about to be uncovered.